Landlord Insurance of 2025

Discover the best Landlord Insurance.

What is Landlord Insurance?

Landlord Insurance is a type of insurance policy designed specifically for property owners who rent out their homes or buildings.

It provides coverage for risks associated with rental properties, such as property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income due to unforeseen events.

1financially’s Picks Of Best Landlord Insurance

Allstate

Allstate

AM Best Rating: A+

Monthly Cost: $184.15

Multi-policy Discount: Available

Pros and cons
  • Amica offers options for home-sharing coverage, which can be added to your policy if you rent out your home or part of it on platforms like Airbnb or Vrbo. This coverage helps protect against risks associated with renting out your property, such as damage caused by guests
  • Amica provides a variety of optional add-ons to customize your homeowners insurance policy. These add-ons can include coverage for water backup, replacement cost for personal belongings, and enhanced protection for valuable items such as computers and business property.
  • Amica does not offer an option to purchase homeowners insurance online. To acquire a policy, you’ll need to contact their representatives directly.
  • Amica’s homeowners insurance is not available in California.
Allstate Home Insurance Overview

Although Allstate didn’t secure the top spot in any of our sub-ratings, it performed strongly across the board, ranking in the top two or three in most categories except for the cheapest homeowners insurance companies, where it is No. 4. Notably, Allstate is ranked second for both best homeowners insurance companies for claims handling and best value.

Allstate offers a range of add-ons for its standard policy. You can select from common extras such as coverage for water backups and valuable items, as well as less common options like coverage for home sharing or upgrades to more energy-efficient items following a covered loss. If you run a home business, higher limits for business property are also available.

While you can obtain quotes through Allstate’s website, purchasing a homeowners insurance policy requires working with an agent.

Availability: Allstate provides policies in 49 states and Washington, D.C. However, as of June 2023, new policies are not being issued in California. Residents seeking an online quote in California will be redirected to Hippo, an online insurance provider owned by Allstate.

StateFarm

Monthly Cost: $170.89

AM Best Rating: A++

Quote Access: Online Estimate

Pros and cons
  • Allstate offers a broad range of coverage options, including standard add-ons like protection for water backups and valuable items, as well as specialized options such as home-sharing coverage and upgrades to energy-efficient items after a covered loss. You can also get higher coverage limits for business property if you run a home business.
  • Allstate has an extensive network of agents, providing personalized service and support to help you navigate your insurance needs and tailor your policy to your requirements.
  • Allstate’s homeowners insurance is not available in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island.
  • Fewer discounts offered compared to other insurers in our rating
  • To purchase a homeowners insurance policy from Allstate, you need to work with an agent. Online purchases are not available.
Overview

State Farm performed well in our sub-ratings, with scores ranging from average to above average across the board. It achieved its highest ranking as No. 2 for the cheapest homeowners insurance companies, with an average monthly premium of nearly $171. Additionally, it is tied for third place among homeowners insurance companies most likely to be renewed.

State Farm provides a range of options to enhance your policy, including coverage for identity theft, home systems, service lines, and energy-efficient upgrades (replacing damaged items with more energy-efficient ones). It also offers increased coverage limits for business property and valuable personal belongings.

With a large network of agents nationwide, State Farm ensures personalized service, though you must purchase your policy through an agent. After purchasing, you can manage your policy, pay premiums, and file and track claims using its mobile app.

Availability: State Farm offers new policies in 47 states and Washington, D.C., but does not issue new homeowners policies in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island.

Farmers

Monthly Cost: Online estimate.

AM Best Rating: A

J.D. Power’s customer satisfaction score: 873/1,000.

Pros and cons
  • Lost rental income coverage lasts up to 18 months.
  • Coverage of multiple units under a single policy.
  • Standard landlord policies are less comprehensive than others listed here.
Overview

Farmers’ standard landlord insurance mainly covers dwelling property and liability, which may not be as extensive as some competitors. However, it offers optional add-ons like landlord’s personal property or coverage for other structures. One standout feature is the optional lost rental income coverage, which can extend for up to 18 months, compared to the typical 12 months offered by others.

Farmers also provides unique advantages such as the ability to consolidate multiple units under a single policy and helpful tools like SmartMove to assist with tenant screening. Claims can be initiated through various channels, including phone, text, website, or mobile app, and customers can track claims through an online portal.

Basic policies tend to be more affordable, though this may reflect their less comprehensive coverage. However, bundling options (like business auto insurance) and discounts for renovated properties can further reduce costs. To get a personalized quote, prospective policyholders can contact a local agent.

Farmers enjoys a strong reputation for customer service, with an A rating from the Better Business Bureau and a customer satisfaction score of 873 out of 1,000 in J.D. Power’s Property Claims Satisfaction Study. The company also holds solid financial strength ratings from Moody’s, AM Best, and S&P, reassuring policyholders of its financial reliability.

Coverage Overview of Landlord Insurance

Landlord insurance typically includes the following key coverages:

  1. Property Damage
    • Covers the rental property’s structure and attached fixtures from damage caused by events like:
      • Fire
      • Storms
      • Vandalism
      • Natural disasters (e.g., wind, hail).
  2. Liability Protection
    • Provides coverage if a tenant or visitor gets injured on the property and the landlord is held responsible.
    • Covers legal fees and medical expenses related to such claims.
  3. Loss of Rental Income
    • Compensates for lost rental income if the property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event (e.g., fire or flooding).
  4. Optional Coverages (Add-Ons):
    • Contents Coverage: Protects appliances, furniture, or other landlord-owned items in the rental unit.
    • Flood or Earthquake Insurance: Covers damages from natural disasters not included in standard policies.
    • Rent Guarantee Insurance: Reimburses unpaid rent if tenants default on payments.
    • Legal Expense Coverage: Assists with legal costs related to disputes with tenants.

These coverages ensure landlords are financially protected from the unique risks associated with renting out property.

Is Landlord Insurance Very Important ?

landlord insurance is essential for protecting both:

  1. Property Investment
    Landlord insurance safeguards the physical structure of the property, ensuring that the landlord’s investment is protected from risks like fire, storms, vandalism, or accidents.
  2. Income Stream
    In the event of damage that makes the rental property uninhabitable, landlord insurance provides compensation for lost rental income. This coverage ensures that landlords can maintain a steady cash flow even if their property is temporarily out of service due to unforeseen events.
  3. Liability
    If a tenant or visitor is injured on the property and the landlord is found liable, liability coverage helps pay for legal costs and medical bills. This prevents significant out-of-pocket expenses and potential financial ruin from lawsuits or claims.

Types of Landlord Insurance Coverage

  1. Building Insurance (Property Damage)
    • Covers the physical structure of the rental property, including walls, roof, floors, and other permanent fixtures.
    • Protects against damages from fire, storms, vandalism, theft, or other insured risks.
  2. Liability Insurance
    • Protects the landlord if a tenant or visitor is injured on the property due to the landlord’s negligence (e.g., failing to repair a broken stair).
    • Covers legal fees, medical bills, and any compensation awarded to the injured party.
  3. Loss of Rent Coverage
    • Provides compensation for lost rental income if the property becomes uninhabitable due to damage from an insured event (e.g., fire or storm).
    • Helps landlords maintain cash flow while repairs are made.
  4. Contents Insurance
    • Covers the landlord’s personal property within the rental unit, such as furniture, appliances, or fixtures, in case of damage or theft.
    • This is useful if the rental property is furnished or includes essential appliances.
  5. Rent Guarantee Insurance
    • Offers protection in case tenants fail to pay rent on time or default on payments.
    • Ensures the landlord continues to receive rental income, even in cases of tenant non-payment.
  6. Legal Expenses Coverage
    • Helps cover the costs of legal fees associated with disputes over tenant agreements, eviction proceedings, or property-related issues.
    • Can also assist in recovering unpaid rent or handling lawsuits filed by tenants.
  7. Accidental Damage Insurance
    • Covers unintentional damages caused by tenants, such as broken windows, spilled paint, or damaged carpets.
    • Provides additional protection for unexpected incidents that may not be covered by standard property damage policies.

Each type of coverage is tailored to the specific needs of the landlord and the property in question, offering a customized protection plan.

Cost of Landlord Insurance

Typically, the annual premium ranges from $1,000 to $3,000 or more. The exact cost depends on the following factors:

1. Property Location

  • High-risk areas (e.g., flood zones, regions prone to natural disasters, or areas with higher crime rates) lead to higher premiums.
  • Properties in more stable areas with fewer risks generally cost less to insure.

2. Property Type and Size

  • Larger properties, multi-unit buildings, or commercial rental spaces typically incur higher premiums due to the greater value and potential liabilities.
  • Single-family homes generally have lower premiums compared to apartment buildings or commercial properties.

3. Coverage Level

  • More comprehensive coverage (such as including loss of rent, legal expenses, or higher liability limits) increases the premium.
  • Basic policies without add-ons tend to be more affordable.

4. Deductibles

  • Higher deductibles generally lower the premium cost, but this means the landlord will pay more out-of-pocket if a claim is made.
  • Lower deductibles increase the premium but reduce out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim.

5. Property Value and Condition

  • More expensive properties or older properties might cost more to insure. Well-maintained properties can also lead to lower premiums compared to those in poor condition.
  • Properties with updated electrical systems, plumbing, or roof improvements may qualify for lower rates.

6. Claims History

  • Landlords with a history of multiple claims may face higher premiums.
  • A clean claims history, on the other hand, could lead to discounts or more favorable rates.

7. Add-Ons and Optional Coverage

  • Including additional coverages (e.g., flood insurance, rent guarantee insurance, or contents coverage) will increase the overall cost of the policy.

Average Annual Premiums

  • Single-family home: Typically ranges from $1,000 to $1,500 per year.
  • Multi-family properties: Premiums can range from $1,500 to $3,000 or more, depending on the number of units.
  • High-risk areas or luxury properties: Could cost significantly more.

Ways to Lower Premiums

  • Bundle landlord insurance with other policies (e.g., homeowners insurance) for discounts.
  • Maintain a higher deductible.
  • Invest in safety features (like smoke detectors or security systems) to reduce risk.

How to Choose the Right Landlord Insurance?

You should :

1. Assess Your Property’s Risks

  • Location: Consider the risks associated with your property’s location. Properties in high-risk areas may require specialized coverage like flood or earthquake insurance.
  • Property Type: Different types of rental properties (single-family homes, multi-unit buildings, commercial properties) have varying risks and coverage needs.
  • Tenants: Think about the type of tenants renting your property (long-term tenants vs. short-term renters like Airbnb). This may influence the kind of coverage you’ll need, such as accidental damage coverage.

2. Determine the Coverage You Need

  • Basic Coverage: At a minimum, ensure your policy includes property damage (for the building) and liability insurance.
  • Additional Coverage: Consider add-ons like loss of rent, contents insurance, legal expenses, and rent guarantee insurance. These extra coverages can protect you against unexpected events that may not be covered by a basic policy.
  • Loss of Rent: If your property could be temporarily uninhabitable due to repairs, make sure your policy covers lost rental income.

3. Compare Multiple Insurance Providers

  • Shop around and get quotes from different insurance companies. Each provider may offer varying coverage options, premiums, and customer service.
  • Look at customer reviews, claim settlement processes, and the insurer’s reputation for reliability.

4. Understand the Terms and Exclusions

  • Exclusions: Carefully read the fine print to understand what is and isn’t covered by the policy. For example, most policies may exclude damage caused by floods or earthquakes, which might require separate coverage.
  • Policy Limits: Pay attention to coverage limits, as some policies may only cover part of the property’s value or have caps on liability coverage.

5. Consider Your Budget and Deductibles

  • Choose a deductible that you are comfortable paying in the event of a claim. Higher deductibles can lower your premiums but will require more out-of-pocket expenses if a claim arises.
  • Balance cost and coverage: Opt for adequate coverage, but ensure the premiums fit within your budget.

6. Review Policy Renewal Terms

  • Ensure the insurer offers flexible renewal terms. If you plan to keep your property for the long term, make sure your policy can be easily renewed and updated as needed.
  • Some insurers may offer loyalty discounts or incentives for long-term policyholders.

Key Considerations:

  • Coverage Limits: Ensure that the limits of coverage are appropriate for your property’s value and potential liabilities.
  • Claims Process: Investigate the claims process—an easy and fast claims process can be critical during emergencies.
  • Customer Support: Choose an insurer that offers strong customer support and clear communication, especially in case you need to file a claim.